Our Mystery Lip Balm is a one-of-a-kind creation, blending unique flavors into a tantalizing treat that keeps you guessing with every swipe. It’s not a repackaged favorite, it’s something entirely new and deliciously intriguing.
Infused with organic Shea Butter, this balm doesn’t just deliver a sensory adventure, it keeps your lips soft, smooth, and perfectly hydrated. Sweet, spicy, fruity, or floral OR does it have it all? You’ll have to try it to uncover the secret. Go ahead, add a little mystery to your lip care routine. Let us know what you think it is.
“The flavor is spot on and the scent is just right, not too strong, just really enjoyable.”
“So smooth and creamy. I keep one in my bag, one by my bed, and one in the car.”
20+ years of perfecting that just right texture. Creamy, smooth, and lightweight for irresistibly soft lips.
Plant-based, certified cruelty-free. Never tested on animals.
Big on flavor, never boring. Made with real, food grade flavors you’ll keep reaching for.
Glides on buttery smooth
Easy to use, mess free.
Real flavors you'll love
Moisturizing Shea, soothing Jojoba
Overall rating: 4.7941175 / 5 from 34 reviews.
Mystery Lip Balm offers a unique lip care experience with its intriguing blend of flavors and organic Shea Butter, providing soft, smooth, and hydrated lips. While opinions on the scent are mixed, the flavor is generally well-received.
Review topics: [].
"I don’t know what flavour this is, maybe apricot with a bit of citrus maybe lemon or orange? What I do know is it tastes delicious and addictive. It’s lovely and moisturising on the lips too, makes a great lip sleeping mask!"
"delicious taste and scent, I can't quite identify it but it is really good, fruity, candy like, leaves my lips soft, hydrated, shiny, and smooth."
"I LOVE IT!!!! I don't know what it is, but it smells fabulous and works GREAT!!!"
"This was included in the order I got today for free. I’d have probably never tried it just because I’d be scared I wouldn’t like it but now I wish they’d to the mystery flavor for a year and the name and release it into the balms at the end of the year and do another one each year. To me I get pink starburst and I love it."
"I think this smells like sherbert. Orange sherbert. It smells super yummy and I really love it. Like many of the other Crazy Rumors balms, it's super smooth and moisturizing. I find that some flavors are not as moisturizing and I'm sure it's due to the different flavor oils used but this one is very moisturizing and I reach for it often."
"Love the flavor and the way it protects my lips."
"I don’t want to spoil the mystery."
"This one is very mysterious... fruity...nutty...hmmm not sure, but I love it and need a BIGGIE!!!"
"Very moisturizing and smooth. I still can’t figure out the scent."
"This was the flavor I rec'd a few years back when I subscribed to a monthly cruelty-free box. My little grand- niece's new word is "mystery", so when I found that out I had to order this one for her, some for the rest of her family, and, of course, some for me!"
Your cart is currently empty
Shop now
